Nicolle Wallace and Malcolm Turnbull in March 2024. Image: MSNBC

Nicolle Wallace hosts the early evening 90-minute MSNBC show Deadline: White House. Wallace’s Australian talking-head-of-choice appears to be former—as in very former—Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull.

I’ve been listening to the podcast version of Deadline on and off for the past year or so and don’t recall much Australian-specific content or many Australian guests, but our Mal’s been on Nicolle’s show a couple times recently – almost a year ago to the day, then on 6 November and most recently on the podcast edition that I listened to the early hours of Monday morning.

As Bernard Keane pointed out in Monday’s Crikey, serving Australian politicians have said little more than “Boo” in terms of policy reactions to Trump’s thuggery:

… the policy options on offer: Labor pretending that everything will be fine if we don’t upset Trump; the Coalition wanting to throw taxpayer money at him to stay in his good books.

At least Malcolm Turnbull is prepared to stir the possum and to call out Labor and the Coalition for gaslighting the Australian public. Mal’s a presentable kinda guy who can string more than a few coherent sentences together and—even if he is pretty much out of any relevant loop nowadays—he’s always good for a few words to fill some prime-time scheduling and content gaps.

Nicole runs a pretty tight show with a rotating list of guests over the hour and a half show and our Mal got a solid ten minutes or so squeezed between some heavy hitters, including journalist and historian Anne Applebaum, retired US Army lieutenant colonel Alexander Vindman, Michael Crawley of the New York Times and former CIA Director John Brennan.

The following transcript of Malcolm Turnbull’s conversation with Nicolle Wallace and Anne Applebaum was broadcast earlier today and has been (lightly) edited for legibility and length.

Deadline: White House

Nicolle Wallace, Anne Applebaum and Malcolm Turnbull – 3 March 2025

Nicolle Wallace: I want to add to our conversation the former Prime Minister of Australia Malcolm Turnbull. Mr. Prime Minister, let me read you something that Liz Cheney tweeted today: ‘Generations of American Patriots from our revolution onward have fought for the principles Zelenskyy is risking his life to defend, but today Donald Trump and J.D. Vance attacked Zelenskyy and pressured him to surrender the freedom of his people to the KGB war criminal who invaded Ukraine. History will remember this day when an American president and vice president abandoned all that we stand for.’ Is that how you see it?

Malcolm Turnbull: Well, I think it’s a fair comment but it’s very clear that Donald Trump and J.D. Vance believe that might is right. Trump described Putin as having made a genius move when he invaded Ukraine in 2022. So, if your view of the world is that might is right, that the strong can do as they will and the weak must suffer as they must, that is at odds with everything the United States has stood for—as John Brennan said—for the last 80 years.

So, we’re dealing with a radically different United States and one, you know where Putin is … there is no criticism of Putin for his crimes. It is a completely different world.

It is a dog-eat dog world and Trump’s view is that America is the biggest dog …


… therefore it just can reorder the world as it wishes – presumably with the other great powers like China and Russia. But it’s really … it’s such a radically different landscape that all of America’s allies have got to come to terms with.

Wallace: How far into the effort of doing what you just articulated … reordering, the world did Trump and Vance go today?

Turnbull: Well, I think this is not just a one-off. I mean this is a very colourful example of what we’re talking about and in a sense it’s a bit where people are telling you what they really think and what they really believe. As Anne Applebaum said, J. D. Vance provoked this furore in the Oval Office. Quite why he did that I have no idea.

Imagine if that that sort of language was used against Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of Israel.

All the same points could be made. It could be made. They could make that point to every single ally of the United States … every single ally basically. They could say to the British, or the Australians, or the Canadians or anyone. French. ‘You’re a smaller country, you can’t defend yourself without our help, so you’ve got to knuckle under and do as we say.’
I mean this is not the United States – or the values of the United States – that we grew up with.
This is a massive change. And I think you know … Trump … it’s one thing to say, ‘America first,’ but I don’t think people really understood – not enough people understood – how far that went. So, it’s a very challenging moment for us all.

Wallace: What is the degree of conversation – absent the United States – with the United States’ traditional allies this morning?

Turnbull: Nicole that is absolutely the key issue. When I was in office I used to talk about sovereign autonomy, I believed that we – Australia – should find our security within Asia. I saw our security as being more of a mesh, we had to do more with our neighbours, with like-minded countries in our region, including Japan, of course and not simply view the world as a series of spokes going into the big hub of Washington … into the imperial capital.
That was a fair point to make then, it is absolutely vital now that we recognise that we cannot count on the United States in the way we thought we could.

There are people in in my country – there’s an election coming up – both sides of politics are engaged in what I call bipartisan gaslighting …


… trying to pretend nothing has changed.

I can understand why a politician would do that when an election is so close, but we’ve been mugged by reality here.
We can’t change the United States; we certainly can’t change Donald Trump, but we have to collaborate more together, and we have to work together, and work to ensure that we have the ability to defend ourselves if it comes to the crunch without the U.S.
Now, that will mean – and this where will really work against America’s interest and this is, I think, the point that your panellists have been making – is that it will cause a number of countries to hedge closer to Russia; but here in the Asia Pacific it will cause a lot of countries to hedge closer to China.

You can see ASEAN saying right, ‘We can’t count on the Americans … maybe we better become more accommodating.’


You can see ASEAN [the Association of Southeast Asian Nations] saying right, ‘We can’t count on the Americans … the Americans keep on urging us to stand up to China and resist China. Well, maybe we better become more accommodating.’
It’s a retreat, this is a retreat of America from the world, and I don’t think that’ll be good.

It will be bad for the world – particularly the free world – but it’ll be bad for America as well. And it’s wrong too; I mean, you’re essentially falling down on the side of tyrants and dictators.

Wallace: Anne Applebaum, I just want to pull you back in with the same question about our European friends and allies. I think for so many of these conversations you cling to how out of step Trump is with the country – 81 percent of all Americans distrusting Putin. With his own party Lindsey Graham in Munich 11 days ago said to Zelenskyy’s face, ‘You’re the best kind of ally America has; fighting our enemies so we don’t have to,’ essentially. 48 hours ago Marco Rubio praised Zelenskyy, and today they’ve all turned on him completely and helped Trump and Vance roll the bus over him. How does that reverberate across Europe?

Anne Applebaum: I mean, it’s funny that you point to the reactions of people around Trump because I think that’s one of the most confusing things for American allies and I’m sure that’s the case in Europe and I would guess also in Asia.
It’s confusing to see Americans – whom everybody is used to thinking of as independent-minded, free-spirited, talkative, open. Those are the qualities of American politicians and diplomats that people have admired even when they didn’t always like American policies and to see this strange atmosphere around the president that people shift, and they change their minds, and they delete their Tweets and they and they take try to take back things that they said a day or two before. I think that’s, that’s a big part of the story, too.
People feel that there’s a domestic change inside the United States that they don’t really understand and that’s also affecting foreign policy and it also affects perceptions of the United States around the world too.

********************************************

Something Bernard Keane wrote in Crikey on Monday reminded me that in 2016, while Turnbull was prime minister, we entered into a deal with the French to build 12 conventional diesel-electric submarines. That deal was summarily cancelled by Turnbull’s successor Scott Morrison in September 2021.

On Monday Bernard Keane suggested that:

If Anthony Albanese was capable of moving fast — which he isn’t — he’d immediately send Malcolm Turnbull on a trip to the Élysée Palace to beg Emmanuel Macron to find out if he can get Naval Group to agree to build nuclear submarines off the shelf for Australia. Chances are the bill would be a fraction of the $368 billion we’ve signed up for.

As fanciful as that prospect might appear on face value, Turnbull has plenty of skin in the “lets-get-the-French-talking-submarines-again” game. As James Curran noted in this piece in The Australian Financial Review in July 2024:

In an exclusive interview with The Australian Financial Review, former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull has revealed that at his own initiative in the early months of 2022, he had confidential discussions with French President Emmanuel Macron and senior French foreign affairs officials to ensure that Canberra and Paris could turn the page on tensions and get their submarine deal back on track.

…

Turnbull told the Financial Review that after Labor won the election in May 2022, he had direct contact with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, Foreign Minister Penny Wong and Defence Minister Richard Marles on the matter of resuscitating the French deal. They listened, but no action was taken. Turnbull was unable to persuade the new Labor government. The political decision to follow Morrison on AUKUS had been taken the year before and there was no appetite in Canberra to even consider a change of course.

…

Turnbull met with Macron and his chief Asia adviser, Walid Fouque, at the Elysee Palace on June 22, 2022. During that same visit, he also met with two senior officials at France’s foreign ministry, the Quai D’Orsay. They were Philippe Errera, Director-General for Political Affairs and Security, and Bertrand Lortholary, then head of the ministry’s Asia division. Lortholary is now France’s ambassador to China.

…

Turnbull acknowledges the opportunity to revive the French partnership has now passed. “That window of opportunity has closed.”

Watch this space … Canberra’s appetite for a “change of course” on the AUKUS Deal may well be revived, particularly as the UK may now be convinced that the French would be willing to accept a revived Australian offer.

********************************************

PS: Finally, it appears that our Mal can’t take a trick – or rather, the Americans can’t help but get his name or title wrong. Not only did hapless White House press secretary Sean Spicer infamously call out Prime Minister Turnbull back in 2017 as ‘Prime Minister Trumble‘ but a few days later the official White House communique listed him as the ‘President of Australia.’
Closing out today’s segment Nicolle Wallace thanked ‘Anne Applebaum and Ambassador Turnbull. Your insights are vital.’

********************************************