Caged birds at an Indian market

A robin redbreast in a cage

Puts all heaven in a rage.

A dove-house filled with doves and pigeons

Shudders hell through all its regions.

…

A skylark wounded in the wing,

A cherubim does cease to sing.

The game-cock clipped and armed for fight

Does the rising sun affright.

Auguries of Innocence, William Blake

Their wings and tail feathers are cut, their wings are sello-taped together and rings are put on their feet…nothing can be more heinous than such acts and there cannot be more glaring example of atrocity and inhumanity.

They are the words of the Hon’ble Mr. Justice Mukesh R. Shah, Judge of the High Court of Gujarat giving his judgement in response to  “bunch of petitions” filed last year by bird sellers of Surat demanding custody of 494 birds confiscated by police under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 and under section 12 of the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972.

Speaking of the birds, held captive by the sellers in cages, Mr. Justice Shah said that it was the fundamental right of birds to fly in the open sky and their confinement was violation of their right to live freely.

The issue raised by the petitions was whether birds have a right to live freely and whether they can be kept in cages.

Law et al News reports that:

Surat police had arrested several persons for violation of Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act. The accused were allegedly found selling the birds in open market while their wings and tails were cut, cello-tape was put on their wings and there were rings on their legs so that they could not fly.

The accused were arrested and the birds were taken into custody of police as ‘muddamaal‘ articles. Though, after this, the accused moved an application to get the custody of the birds. This application was rejected by the concerned magisterial court while ordering to set the birds free in open sky.

This order was challenged in the Sessions Court in the form of a revision application. And the Sessions Court quashed the order of the magisterial court to set the birds free and ordered to give custody of the birds to a voluntary organisation. Following this order, the magisterial court also passed an order imposing cost of Rs 1.05 lakhs on the accused for maintenance of the birds to the voluntary organisation.

Aggrieved by this order, the accused moved the High Court. The voluntary organisation also moved the High Court while seeking order to set the birds free.

After hearing the concerned parties, the bench of Justice MR Shah reinstated the original order passed by the magisterial court and ordered to set the birds free after doing panchnama of the same.

While passing the order, Justice Shah emphasised the importance of fundamental rights of the birds to fly in open sky.

Criticising the manner in which the birds were kept, the court observed:

“Nobody has a right to inflict pain or suffering to others inclusive of the animals and birds. Even birds can not be kept in cages by which they suffer a pain. To keep birds in cages would tantamount to illegal confinement of the birds which is in violation of right of the birds to live in free air / sky.”

“It is the fundamental right of the bird to live freely in the open sky.” As stated above, it is the duty of every citizen to see that there is no unnecessary pain or suffering to any animal or bird,” he added.

Justice Shah also observed, “When everybody is talking about fundamental rights of the citizen, such as, right to live freely, right to food, right to move freely etc. a day has come to think about the rights of the birds and animals, because of such act even the birds have vanished and their numbers are in decrease.”

The Times of India reports that the animal rights organisation ‘People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals’ (PETA), on Wednesday, announced conferral of an award on Justice M R Shah.

Lauding the judgment, PETA, India announced that the judge would receive its ‘Compassionate Action Award‘ for his compassionate decision. Sources, however, doubt if the judge will accept the award.

PETA’s India branch has been running a campaign against the keeping of caged birds for the past few years, and like many of their campaigns worldwide, have made clever use of celebritues to promote their cause. Here is a picture of Bollywood star John Abraham from 2009:

Bollywood star John Abraham. Picture by PETA

Indian celebrity website Look to The Stars says that model turned actor John Abraham has championed independence for caged birds by modeling with an empty bird-cage on Indian Independence Day in the past.

“Independence Day should spell freedom for all – humans and animals alike”, said John. “Birds aren’t meant to learn silly human words or swing in a cage. They are supposed to fly free in the skies and sing songs for each other.”

I’d like to think that the good Justice’s words will ring loud and clear across the globe…but somehow I doubt it.

Your thoughts are welcome…